Why Saudi Arabia And Iran Are Arch-Rivals: A Deep Dive Into Their Complex Conflict

Curt Torp 19 Jun 2025

Introduction
Historical Roots of a Deep-Seated Rivalry
The Enduring Schism: Sunni vs. Shia Islam
- Iran: The World's Leading Shiite Powerhouse
- Saudi Arabia: The Birthplace of Islam and Sunni Dominance
Geopolitical Ambition: The Naked Struggle for Regional Dominance
The Battlefield of Proxies: From Yemen to Libya
- Echoes of the Iran-Iraq War
- The Post-Arab Spring Power Vacuum
Specific Flashpoints and Escalating Tensions
Ethnic and Cultural Differences: Arab vs. Persian
External Factors and the Limits of Conflict
Conclusion: A Rivalry Without Easy Answers

Introduction

**The Middle East, a region perpetually at the crossroads of history, religion, and power, is often defined by its intricate web of alliances and animosities. At the heart of many regional conflicts lies the profound and often volatile rivalry between two of its most influential players: Saudi Arabia and Iran. These two nations are at loggerheads, their relationship characterized by deep-seated mistrust and open hostility. While they have long been rivals, it's all recently got a lot more tense, escalating into a multifaceted struggle for supremacy that reverberates across the globe.** Understanding why does Saudi Arabia hate Iran, or perhaps more accurately, why these two powerful states are locked in such an unrelenting rivalry, requires a meticulous examination of historical grievances, ideological divides, and competing geopolitical ambitions. This article will delve into the complex layers of this animosity, exploring the historical, religious, political, and economic dimensions that fuel this enduring conflict. This isn't merely a clash of personalities or transient political disagreements; it's a profound competition rooted in differing visions for the Middle East, each nation seeing itself as the rightful leader of the Muslim world. Saudi Arabia and Iran wrap themselves in the righteousness of faith, but at the centre is the naked ambition of survival, influence, and what it means to be a, or perhaps the most, powerful Muslim nation. Their struggle is a high-stakes game for regional superiority, with proxy wars and diplomatic standoffs becoming the norm.

Historical Roots of a Deep-Seated Rivalry

The modern chapter of the Saudi-Iranian rivalry largely begins with the 1979 Iranian Revolution. Prior to this pivotal event, while differences existed, the relationship was not always one of outright hostility. In 1968, for instance, Saudi Arabia and Iran signed a demarcation agreement. This period saw a degree of cooperation, particularly when the United Kingdom announced it would withdraw and vacate the Persian Gulf in the late 1960s. In the vacuum of British power, Iran and Saudi Arabia took the primary responsibility for peace and security in the region. The Shah of Iran, in the late 1960s, even sent a series of letters to King Faisal, urging him to foster greater regional collaboration. This historical snapshot reveals a period where both nations, despite their inherent differences, saw a shared interest in regional stability and self-reliance. However, the 1979 Iranian Revolution fundamentally altered this dynamic. The overthrow of the Western-backed Shah and the establishment of an Islamic Republic, with its revolutionary ideology aiming to export its model across the Muslim world, sent shockwaves through the conservative monarchies of the Gulf, particularly Saudi Arabia. From this point forward, Saudi Arabia and Iran have been archrivals, with the revolutionary zeal of Tehran directly challenging the legitimacy and traditional authority of Riyadh. This ideological clash quickly translated into tangible support for opposing sides in regional conflicts. A stark example of this was during the Iran-Iraq War (1980-1988), where Saudi Arabia supported Iraq financially and politically in its war against Iran, seeing Saddam Hussein’s regime as a bulwark against Iranian expansion. This move cemented the perception of a direct, adversarial relationship.

The Enduring Schism: Sunni vs. Shia Islam

Perhaps the most frequently cited reason for the animosity between Saudi Arabia and Iran is the profound religious and ethnic differences that plague the two regional powers. The schism between Sunni and Shia Islam is an ancient one, dating back to the succession of Prophet Muhammad. This theological divide, expressed today in part through the rivalry between Sunni Saudi Arabia and Shia Iran, is not merely a matter of differing interpretations of faith; it has become a potent political tool, fueling narratives of legitimacy and delegitimization.

Iran: The World's Leading Shiite Powerhouse

Iran is the world's leading Shiite powerhouse, with its government deeply intertwined with its Twelver Shia identity. The Iranian regime views itself as the protector and champion of Shia communities globally, often appealing to Shia populations in countries like Iraq, Lebanon, Syria, and Yemen. This outreach is perceived by Saudi Arabia as direct interference in the internal affairs of other nations and a deliberate attempt to expand Iranian influence at Riyadh's expense. The revolutionary ideology of Iran often frames its actions through a religious lens, seeking to inspire and empower Shia minorities, which further exacerbates Sunni-majority states' fears of an ascendant Shia crescent.

Saudi Arabia: The Birthplace of Islam and Sunni Dominance

Conversely, Saudi Arabia, as the birthplace of Islam and home to its holiest sites (Mecca and Medina), positions itself as the leader of the Sunni Muslim world and the guardian of orthodox Islam. Its ruling family, the House of Saud, derives significant legitimacy from its role as Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques. This position gives Saudi Arabia a unique claim to religious authority, which it sees as directly challenged by Iran's revolutionary Shia ideology. The competition between these two religious poles is intense, manifesting in ideological rhetoric, religious education, and even clashes during sacred events. During the annual pilgrimage in Mecca, for instance, clashes between Iranian pilgrims and Saudi security forces have led to tragic outcomes, including the deaths of over 400 people in one notable incident, highlighting the volatile intersection of faith and politics. This religious dimension is crucial to understanding why does Saudi Arabia hate Iran, as it forms the bedrock of their competing claims to leadership. The rivalry is "a bit like Protestants and Catholics hated each other for a long time (and still do in some places)," as both are competing views on their religion, albeit within the broader framework of Islam. This analogy underscores the deep-seated, often irrational, nature of the animosity when religious identity is intertwined with national identity and political ambition.

Geopolitical Ambition: The Naked Struggle for Regional Dominance

Beyond religious differences, the core of the Saudi-Iranian conflict is a raw struggle for regional dominance. Both Saudi Arabia and Iran are some of the biggest regional powers, competing with each other for influence and control over the Middle East. This competition is not just about territory or resources, but about shaping the future political and security architecture of the region. Each sees the other's success as a direct threat to its own security and strategic interests. In the aftermath of 2011’s Arab Spring, Iran and Saudi Arabia have become the region’s most influential players, vying to fill power vacuums and support allied factions. The Arab Spring uprisings, which destabilized several states, provided fertile ground for both powers to expand their influence through various means, including financial aid, military support, and political backing for proxy groups. This period saw a significant intensification of their rivalry, as both sought to capitalize on the ensuing chaos to advance their respective agendas. The question of why does Saudi Arabia hate Iran becomes clearer when viewed through the lens of this zero-sum game for regional hegemony.

The Battlefield of Proxies: From Yemen to Libya

The direct military confrontation between Saudi Arabia and Iran has largely been avoided, primarily due to the devastating potential consequences. Instead, their rivalry plays out through a series of proxy wars across the Middle East and North Africa. These conflicts allow both nations to weaken the other's influence without engaging in direct, all-out warfare.

Echoes of the Iran-Iraq War

The Iran-Iraq War, as mentioned earlier, was a foundational proxy conflict, with Saudi Arabia supporting Iraq. This established a pattern that would repeat in various forms. In the present day, the conflict in Yemen is perhaps the most prominent example. Saudi Arabia leads a coalition supporting the internationally recognized government against the Houthi rebels, whom Riyadh accuses of being Iranian proxies. Iran, in turn, denies direct military support to the Houthis but expresses political solidarity and humanitarian concern for the Yemeni people. This conflict has become a devastating humanitarian crisis, further entrenching the animosity between Riyadh and Tehran.

The Post-Arab Spring Power Vacuum

The ripple effects of the Arab Spring created numerous new battlegrounds for this proxy struggle. In Syria, Iran has been a staunch supporter of the Assad regime, providing military and financial aid, while Saudi Arabia has supported various rebel groups. In Lebanon, Iran's influence is seen through Hezbollah, a powerful Shia political party and militant group, which Riyadh views as a direct threat to its regional interests. Even in Libya, Iran and Saudi Arabia have waged a proxy war, with Saudi Arabia, along with the UAE, Egypt, and Sudan, providing support to the Libyan National Army and its leader, warlord Khalifa Haftar. These diverse battlefields illustrate the pervasive nature of their competition, demonstrating that their rivalry goes much deeper than surface-level disagreements. The Iranian regime has also accused the Saudi government of influencing, funding, and masterminding separatist activity within Iran, particularly in regions with Sunni or ethnic minority populations. Such accusations, whether fully substantiated or not, highlight the deep mistrust and the belief that each side is actively working to destabilize the other from within. This constant shadow boxing and mutual suspicion contribute significantly to why does Saudi Arabia hate Iran.

Specific Flashpoints and Escalating Tensions

While the underlying reasons for the rivalry are long-standing, specific events often trigger periods of heightened tension. One recent example that brought the world's attention to their escalating row was the execution of a prominent Shia cleric in Saudi Arabia, Nimr al-Nimr, in January 2016. This execution sparked outrage in Iran, leading to attacks on the Saudi embassy in Tehran and its consulate in Mashhad. In response, Saudi Arabia severed diplomatic ties with Iran, a rupture that lasted for several years until a recent rapprochement facilitated by China in 2023. Such incidents underscore the fragility of their relationship and how easily it can descend into crisis. Beyond specific executions or embassy attacks, other points of contention include: * **Iran's Nuclear Program:** Saudi Arabia views Iran's nuclear ambitions with extreme suspicion, fearing it could lead to a nuclear arms race in the region. The leaders of Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and Qatar had, at one point, urged then-President Trump, as he visited the region, not to order US strikes on Iran’s nuclear facilities and to pursue a deal instead, according to reports. This demonstrates the regional concern over the issue and the preference for a diplomatic solution, albeit one that curbs Iran's nuclear capabilities. * **Oil Policy:** Both are major oil producers and often find themselves on opposing sides within OPEC, disagreeing on production quotas and pricing strategies, which adds an economic layer to their rivalry. * **Cyber Warfare:** There have been numerous reports of cyberattacks attributed to both sides, targeting critical infrastructure and government institutions, adding a new, covert dimension to their conflict. These flashpoints, while seemingly isolated, are symptoms of the deeper, systemic struggle between the two powers, reinforcing why does Saudi Arabia hate Iran and vice versa.

Ethnic and Cultural Differences: Arab vs. Persian

While often overshadowed by the religious and geopolitical aspects, ethnic and cultural differences also play a subtle but significant role in the rivalry. Iran is mostly Persian and Shia, with a distinct cultural heritage that predates Islam. Saudi Arabia, on the other hand, is mostly Arab and Sunni, deeply rooted in Arab tribal traditions and the birthplace of the Arabic language. This distinction is not merely academic. It contributes to a sense of "otherness" and can be exploited by hardliners on both sides to foster nationalist sentiments against the rival. The historical legacy of the Persian Empire and the Arab Caliphates, while ancient, can sometimes be invoked in modern narratives of regional leadership and cultural superiority. This underlying cultural divergence adds another layer of complexity to the already multifaceted question of why does Saudi Arabia hate Iran.

External Factors and the Limits of Conflict

The Saudi-Iranian rivalry is not played out in a vacuum. External powers, particularly the United States, Russia, China, and even Israel, significantly influence the dynamics of their relationship. The US, traditionally a strong ally of Saudi Arabia and a staunch opponent of the Iranian regime, has often exacerbated tensions, though recent administrations have also sought de-escalation. Israel, viewing Iran as an existential threat, often aligns with Saudi Arabia's concerns about Iranian expansionism. However, these external factors also impose limits on the conflict. Finally, Saudi Arabia cannot fight a winning war with Iran because its powerful regional and Western allies, particularly Israel and the United States, are not willing to make major sacrifices on its behalf that could lead to a broader, more devastating regional conflict. The potential for a direct military confrontation to spiral out of control, drawing in major global powers and disrupting global oil supplies, acts as a powerful deterrent. This delicate balance of power, coupled with the international community's desire for stability, often forces both Riyadh and Tehran to resort to proxy conflicts rather than direct military engagement.

Conclusion: A Rivalry Without Easy Answers

The question of why does Saudi Arabia hate Iran is not reducible to a single cause. It is a complex tapestry woven from historical grievances, profound religious and ethnic divides, and a relentless geopolitical struggle for regional dominance. From the aftermath of the 1979 Iranian Revolution and the Iran-Iraq War to the proxy battles in Yemen and Libya, and the constant ideological clashes, their rivalry has shaped the Middle East for decades. The small Middle Eastern countries of Saudi Arabia and Iran are renowned for their unrelenting rivalry in which both countries play out a struggle for regional superiority. This informative video, we have examined the ongoing tension between these two major powers in the Middle East. It is a rivalry driven by a zero-sum mentality, where one's gain is perceived as the other's loss, fueled by mutual suspicion and a deep-seated desire for influence and survival. While recent diplomatic efforts, such as the China-brokered rapprochement, offer a glimmer of hope for de-escalation, the fundamental drivers of their animosity remain. Understanding this multifaceted conflict is crucial for comprehending the dynamics of the Middle East and the broader implications for global stability. What are your thoughts on the future of this complex rivalry? Do you believe a lasting peace is possible, or are their differences too profound to overcome? Share your insights in the comments below, and don't forget to share this article with anyone interested in understanding the intricate geopolitics of the Middle East. For more deep dives into regional conflicts, explore our other articles on Middle Eastern affairs.

Why you should start with why

Why Text Question · Free image on Pixabay

UTILITY COMPANIES MAKE MISTAKES - WHY? - Pacific Utility Auditing

HeadlineSphere