Unraveling The Decades-Long Enmity: Why Iran And Israel Are Enemies

Jackie Quigley DVM 21 Jun 2025

The Middle East, a region perpetually on edge, frequently sees its geopolitical landscape shaped by deep-seated rivalries. Few are as complex, enduring, and potentially volatile as the one between Iran and Israel. For decades, the question of why Iran and Israel are enemies has puzzled observers, as what began as a cold standoff rooted in nuclear ambitions and ideological rivalry now threatens to ignite the entire region, with the world watching with bated breath. This article delves into the historical, ideological, and strategic layers that define this bitter animosity, tracing its origins from an unlikely alliance to a state of overt conflict.

Understanding the intricate tapestry of this hostility requires looking beyond recent headlines. It’s a story of shifting alliances, revolutionary fervor, existential fears, and a relentless shadow war that has, on multiple occasions, erupted into direct confrontation. From Tehran's revolutionary rhetoric to Israel's security doctrines, every move by one side is seen through the lens of the other's perceived threat, creating a dangerous feedback loop that continues to destabilize an already fragile part of the world.

The Unthinkable Shift: From Allies to Adversaries
- A Shared Past: Iran and Israel as Friends
- The Turning Point: Iran's 1979 Islamic Revolution
Ideological Bedrock: The Islamic Revolution's Stance
The Nuclear Shadow: Israel's Existential Fear
Proxy Wars and Regional Influence
The Gaza Strip and Beyond: A Catalyst for Conflict
Economic and Legal Entanglements: The Debt Dispute
The Stakes: Why the World is Watching
Navigating the Future: Can the Enmity Be Undone?
- The Deep-Rooted Nature of the Conflict
- Pathways to De-escalation

The Unthinkable Shift: From Allies to Adversaries

To truly grasp why Iran and Israel are enemies today, one must first understand that this was not always the case. For decades, their relationship was one of strategic convenience and even mutual benefit. The dramatic transformation from allies to bitter adversaries is a pivotal chapter in the history of the Middle East, fundamentally altering the region's geopolitical landscape. This shift was not gradual but rather an abrupt and profound reorientation driven by a monumental internal event in Iran.

A Shared Past: Iran and Israel as Friends

In a surprising twist of history for those only familiar with their current animosity, Israel and Iran were allies starting in the 1950s. During the reign of Iran’s last monarch, Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, the two nations found common ground. In fact, Iran was one of the first states to recognize Israel after it was founded in 1948. This alliance was largely pragmatic; Israel regarded Iran as an ally against the Arab states, many of whom were hostile to both nations at different times. The relationship flourished with economic ties, military cooperation, and intelligence sharing. This period of cooperation, though often overlooked in modern narratives, underscores the profound ideological chasm that would later emerge, completely redefining why Iran and Israel are enemies.

The Turning Point: Iran's 1979 Islamic Revolution

The friendship abruptly ended with the 1979 Islamic Revolution in Iran. This seismic event fundamentally reshaped Iran's identity, foreign policy, and its perception of the world. Within days of the Iranian Revolution of 1979, Tehran broke off diplomatic ties with Israel. The new revolutionary leadership immediately identified the U.S., Britain, and Israel as its main enemies. This designation was rooted in their perceived ties to Iran’s deposed monarch and a long history of Western colonialism and military interventions in the Middle East. The revolution ushered in a new era where ideological purity and anti-imperialism became cornerstones of Iranian foreign policy, setting the stage for the enduring question of why Iran and Israel are enemies.

Ideological Bedrock: The Islamic Revolution's Stance

At the heart of the animosity, and a primary reason why Iran and Israel are enemies, lies a profound ideological clash stemming directly from the principles of the 1979 Islamic Revolution. Iran’s theocratic government perceives itself as the vanguard of Islamic resistance against Western domination and injustice in the Muslim world. In this worldview, Israel is not merely a political entity but an outpost of Western influence and an occupier of Muslim lands, particularly Jerusalem.

This ideological conviction has fueled a consistent and often inflammatory rhetoric from Tehran. Iranian leaders have been among the sharpest critics of Israel's military operation in the Gaza Strip and other actions. More disturbingly, Tehran has made no secret of its praise for those who attack Israelis, including various militant groups. The most stark manifestation of this ideological stance is the oft-repeated declaration that Iran wants to wipe Israel off the map and threatens to annihilate it. This rhetoric, deeply embedded in the revolutionary ethos, is a core reason why Israel, for its part, regards Iran as its biggest adversary and an existential threat.

The Nuclear Shadow: Israel's Existential Fear

Beyond ideology, a critical and tangible factor in why Iran and Israel are enemies is Israel's profound concern over Iran's nuclear program. Israel began viewing Iran’s nuclear ambitions as an existential threat decades ago. This fear is not merely theoretical; it is a deeply ingrained security doctrine. Israel's declared goals are to dismantle Iran's nuclear and ballistic missile capabilities, which are seen as existential dangers for Israel. The development of a nuclear weapon by Iran, coupled with its advanced missile technology, would fundamentally alter the balance of power in the Middle East and could potentially lead to a devastating regional conflict.

This concern has driven much of Israel's covert and overt actions against Iran, including alleged sabotage, assassinations of nuclear scientists, and cyberattacks. For Israel, a nuclear-armed Iran, especially one that openly threatens its existence, is an unacceptable scenario. This singular focus on preventing Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons has become a central pillar of Israeli foreign policy, cementing the perception of Iran as its primary and most dangerous adversary. It is a key strategic reason why Iran and Israel are enemies, escalating tensions and often leading to direct confrontations in the shadows and sometimes in the open.

Proxy Wars and Regional Influence

The animosity between Iran and Israel rarely manifests in direct, conventional warfare between their national armies. Instead, their conflict has largely been a "shadow war," fought through proxies across the Middle East. This strategic approach allows both sides to exert influence, challenge the other, and inflict damage without triggering a full-scale regional war. However, as recent events have shown, this shadow war can erupt into overt conflict, marking their most sustained direct fighting ever.

Iran supports various non-state actors and militant groups, such as Hezbollah in Lebanon, Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad in Gaza, and Houthi rebels in Yemen. These groups, often ideologically aligned with Iran's "Axis of Resistance," serve as forward bases to project Iranian power and threaten Israel's borders. Israel, in turn, conducts frequent airstrikes in Syria and Lebanon, targeting Iranian military assets, weapons shipments, and proxy forces to degrade their capabilities and prevent the establishment of a permanent Iranian military presence near its borders. This constant, low-level conflict, punctuated by escalations, is a defining characteristic of why Iran and Israel are enemies, with both sides actively working to undermine the other's regional influence.

The Gaza Strip and Beyond: A Catalyst for Conflict

The ongoing conflict in the Gaza Strip serves as a particularly potent flashpoint and a stark illustration of why Iran and Israel are enemies. Iranian leaders have been among the sharpest critics of Israel's military operation in the Gaza Strip, often condemning it in the strongest terms. This criticism aligns perfectly with Iran's broader ideological stance as the champion of Islamic resistance against perceived injustice.

Tehran has made no secret of its praise for those who attack Israelis, including the militant groups operating from Gaza. While Iran denies direct operational control over these groups, its financial, military, and ideological support is well-documented. For Israel, these groups, backed by Iran, represent a direct and constant threat to its civilian population. The cycles of violence in Gaza inevitably draw in regional actors, further entrenching the positions of both Iran and Israel and reinforcing their adversarial relationship. The Gaza conflict, therefore, is not just a localized dispute but a crucial arena where the broader Iran-Israel enmity plays out, often with devastating consequences.

Economic and Legal Entanglements: The Debt Dispute

Beyond the ideological and strategic dimensions, there are also complex economic and legal disputes that highlight the depth of the animosity and further explain why Iran and Israel are enemies. One notable example involves a long-standing financial dispute dating back to their alliance days. In May 2015, a Swiss court ordered the Eilat Ashkelon Pipeline Company to pay $1.1 billion to Iran. This debt originated from a joint oil pipeline venture established when the two countries were allies.

However, payment of these debts is legally complicated by the international sanctions against Iran and by the fact that Israel classifies Iran as an enemy state. Israel refuses to pay, citing its legal obligation not to conduct financial transactions with an enemy. This seemingly technical legal matter underscores the complete breakdown of trust and normal relations. It demonstrates how even past commercial agreements are now ensnared in the current geopolitical rivalry, with the classification of "enemy state" preventing resolution and perpetuating a state of financial and legal limbo between the two nations.

The Stakes: Why the World is Watching

The tensions between Iran and Israel have erupted into open conflict, marked by airstrikes, drone attacks, and fears of a wider regional war. This is not merely a localized dispute; it is a conflict with profound implications for global stability. What began as a cold standoff rooted in nuclear ambitions and ideological rivalry now threatens to ignite the Middle East, and the world is indeed watching with growing apprehension. The potential for miscalculation, escalation, or a proxy conflict spiraling out of control is ever-present.

The direct confrontations, even if limited in scope, signal a dangerous shift from a covert shadow war to more overt military exchanges. Each retaliatory strike raises the specter of a larger, more devastating conflict that could draw in other regional powers and even global actors. The sheer scale of potential human suffering, economic disruption, and geopolitical instability makes the Iran-Israel enmity a paramount concern for international diplomacy and security.

Navigating the Future: Can the Enmity Be Undone?

The question of whether the deep-seated enmity between Iran and Israel can ever be undone is one that weighs heavily on policymakers and analysts worldwide. The roots of their conflict are so intertwined with historical grievances, revolutionary ideologies, and existential security concerns that finding a pathway to reconciliation appears incredibly challenging.

The Deep-Rooted Nature of the Conflict

Iran and Israel have been enemies for decades, and their conflict is multifaceted. It's not just about specific policies or leaders; it's about fundamental differences in their respective national identities and visions for the region. For Iran, the Islamic Revolution dictates a stance of resistance against perceived Western hegemony, with Israel as a primary symbol of that influence. For Israel, the threat of a nuclear-armed Iran, coupled with its openly hostile rhetoric and support for proxies, represents an existential danger that cannot be ignored. These deeply rooted ideological, security, and geopolitical layers make the conflict incredibly resilient to simple solutions.

Pathways to De-escalation

Despite the immense challenges, the international community continues to seek pathways to de-escalation. Diplomacy, multilateral negotiations, and sustained pressure from global powers are often cited as necessary components. However, any lasting solution would require a fundamental shift in perception and policy from both sides, a willingness to compromise on issues deemed existential, and a re-evaluation of their respective roles in the Middle East. Until such a shift occurs, the world will likely continue to witness the dangerous dance of animosity that defines why Iran and Israel are enemies, hoping that the next escalation does not spiral into an irreversible regional catastrophe.

Conclusion

The complex and perilous relationship between Iran and Israel is a defining feature of contemporary Middle Eastern geopolitics. What began as a pragmatic alliance in the mid-20th century transformed dramatically with Iran's 1979 Islamic Revolution, leading to a profound ideological chasm. This shift saw revolutionary Iran declare Israel an enemy, driven by a vision of Islamic resistance against Western influence. For Israel, Iran's nuclear ambitions and its overt threats of annihilation quickly became an existential concern, solidifying its perception of Iran as its biggest adversary.

The conflict has since evolved into a dangerous shadow war fought through proxies, punctuated by direct military confrontations and fueled by regional flashpoints like the Gaza Strip. Economic disputes, such as the unresolved debt payment, further underscore the depth of their animosity. The stakes are incredibly high, with the world watching nervously as tensions escalate, fearing a wider regional conflagration. Understanding why Iran and Israel are enemies is crucial for comprehending the dynamics of the Middle East and the urgent need for diplomatic efforts to prevent further escalation. Share your thoughts on this critical geopolitical rivalry in the comments below, or explore our other articles on Middle East affairs to deepen your understanding.

Why you should start with why

Why Text Question · Free image on Pixabay

UTILITY COMPANIES MAKE MISTAKES - WHY? - Pacific Utility Auditing

HeadlineSphere